New Baltimore vs Utica: property taxes compared
Utica is the cheaper of the two. Its lowest homestead rate is 40.6467 mills against New Baltimore's 40.8182 — about $30 a year less on a $350,000 home at the uncapped taxable value.
Side by side
| Municipality | Homestead mills | County rank | $250,000 | $350,000 | $500,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Utica | 40.6467 | 15 of 24 | $5,081 | $7,113 | $10,162 |
| New Baltimore | 40.8182 | 16 of 24 | $5,102 | $7,143 | $10,205 |
Dollar columns are the annual homestead bill at the uncapped taxable value — roughly half the purchase price. Multi-district cities show their full rate range; the rank and dollar figures use each city's lowest district.
What the difference costs over time
Held for 10 years, that gap compounds to $300 at today's rates on a $350,000 home — before any millage change. At $250,000 the annual difference is $21; at $500,000 it is $43. The gap scales with price, so it matters more at the top of each city's market than at the bottom.
Neither city splits across districts at different rates, so an address anywhere in New Baltimore pays the 40.8182-mill homestead rate and anywhere in Utica pays 40.6467. The comparison above is the whole story.
All figures use each city's lowest homestead rate at the uncapped taxable value — roughly half the purchase price — from the Michigan Department of Treasury's 2025 Total Rates report. A non-homestead property adds about 18 mills on top in either city.
Common questions
Is New Baltimore or Utica cheaper for property taxes?
Utica is the cheaper of the two. Its lowest homestead rate is 40.6467 mills against New Baltimore's 40.8182 — about $30 a year less on a $350,000 home at the uncapped taxable value.
How much more are property taxes in New Baltimore than Utica?
About $30 a year on a $350,000 home — 40.8182 mills versus 40.6467 at each city's lowest homestead rate, using the official 2025 Michigan Treasury millage report.
Do New Baltimore and Utica share any school districts?
No. New Baltimore and Utica draw from different school districts, so a move between them changes both the city millage and the school levy underneath it.
Will my bill match what the listing shows?
Usually not, in either city. Michigan taxable value uncaps the year after a sale and resets to roughly half the purchase price, so the seller's capped bill on the listing is almost always lower than what you will pay.